Case Study: Boulder Creek Inn – Complete Roof Replacement

All County Roofing completed a full commercial roof replacement for Boulder Creek Inn, a hotel located in Donnelly, Idaho—an area known for extreme mountain weather, including heavy snowfall, ice buildup, and high winds. The existing roof had sustained weather-related damage that required a durable, long-term roofing solution designed specifically for harsh alpine conditions.

The Challenge

Hotels in high-elevation climates face unique roofing demands. This project required materials and installation methods capable of withstanding snow loads, freeze-thaw cycles, and sustained wind exposure—while keeping the property operational with minimal guest disruption.

The Solution

Our team installed Malarkey Vista® Architectural Shingles, selected for their proven wind resistance, impact durability, and long-term performance in cold-weather environments. As experienced commercial roofing contractors, we coordinated the project efficiently and safely, completing the replacement in just seven days while maintaining hotel operations.

The Result

• A fully restored, leak-free roofing system
• Improved wind and weather resistance
• Long-term protection tailored to Idaho’s mountain climate
• A satisfied property owner with renewed confidence in their roof investment

Why This Matters

This project highlights All County Roofing’s expertise in commercial roof replacement, hospitality roofing, and mountain-climate roofing systems across Idaho. From material selection to execution, every detail was engineered for performance, longevity, and minimal disruption.

Project Overview

• Client: Boulder Creek Inn
• Location: 629 ID-55, Donnelly, ID 83615
• Building Type: Hotel
• Project Scope: Complete roof replacement
• Completion Date: 2020

Project Background & Challenges

Boulder Creek Inn, a hotel nestled in the mountainous community of Donnelly, Idaho, faced severe roofing issues due to the region’s extreme winter weather conditions. The existing roof had significant leaks and damage from years of exposure to heavy snowfall, ice accumulation, high winds, and hailstorms. The hotel’s owners needed a durable, long-lasting roofing solution that could withstand the area’s harsh winters and hot summers. Additionally, budget constraints and minimal business disruption were key factors in planning this project.

Challenges Faced

• Severe Weather Conditions: Donnelly Idaho can experience snowfall of up to 20 feet in a single day, along with ice dams, hail, and high winds exceeding 100 mph.
• Structural Stress: Snow and ice created excessive weight on the roof, leading to damage and leaks.
• Business Continuity: The project needed to be completed quickly to avoid impacting hotel operations.

Materials & Roofing System Installed

To ensure the new roof would provide superior protection and longevity, we selected Malarkey Vista Architectural Shingles, a high-performance roofing solution known for its Class 4 hail impact rating, 130 mph wind resistance, and sustainability through the use of recycled materials. Vista® Shingles – Malarkey Roofing Products

https://www.malarkeyroofing.com/products/shingles-overview/vista-shingles/

Additional materials included:

• Arctic Seal Ice & Water Shield – Provides enhanced protection against ice damming and leaks.
• Secure Start® HT Underlayment – A premium metal underlayment for added durability.
• Malarkey Smart Start Starter Shingles – Ensures better adhesion and wind resistance.
• Easy Ridge & High-Profile Roof Ridge – Enhances the finished look and ventilation.
• Snow Country Vented Ridge – Optimizes attic ventilation and energy efficiency.

Installation Process & Execution

• Project Timeline: 7 working days
• Crew Size: 12 skilled roofers
• Safety Measures: Given the height of the building (2-3 stories), our team followed strict OSHA safety protocols, including harnesses and fall protection equipment.
• Step-by-Step Execution:
  • Day 1-2: Manual tear-off of the existing roof, with debris carefully hauled away.
  • Day 3-7: Installation of new underlayment, ice and water shield, and Malarkey Vista shingles.

Results & Client Impact

• Enhanced Protection & Durability: The new roofing system provides leak-free performance, superior wind resistance, and ice protection to withstand Donnelly’s extreme weather conditions.
• Instant Aesthetic Upgrade: The roof gave the hotel an immediate facelift, improving its curb appeal.
• Client Satisfaction: The owners were thrilled with both the price and the efficiency of the installation. The new roof has remained in excellent condition for over 5 years with no reported leaks.
• Increased Business & Referrals: Thanks to the success of this project, we received multiple referrals for additional roofing jobs in the area.

Key Takeaways & What We Learned

• Weather-Resistant Roofing is Critical: In high-altitude mountain environments, choosing the right materials is essential for long-term performance.
• Speed & Efficiency Matter: Completing the job quickly without compromising quality minimized disruptions to hotel operations.
• Safety First: Working on a multi-story building in a challenging climate reinforced the importance of strict safety protocols.

All County Roofing is a Malarkey’s Certified Residential Contractor (CRC): Malarkey Certified Contractors are trained in the installation of Malarkey products, proven through badges of accreditation.